PSYCHIATRY

Depression – HANDI — non-drug options

1. Exercise for depression

  • Intervention
    • Supervised group exercise.
    • Aim for 30–40 minutes, 3 times per week.
    • Minimum duration: 9 weeks.
    • Any exercise is better than none.
    • More sessions generally produce greater mood benefit.
    • Supervised group exercise appears more effective than solo activity.
    • Combination of resistance + aerobic training appears better than aerobic exercise alone.
  • Indication
    • Mild to moderate depression.
    • Subthreshold depressive symptoms.
    • Can be used as:
      • sole therapy in appropriate patients
      • adjunctive therapy with psychological or pharmacological treatment.
    • Has a moderate effect on reducing depressive symptoms.
    • Some evidence suggests it may be comparable to psychological or pharmacological treatments in selected mild–moderate cases.
  • Precautions
    • Not recommended as sole therapy for severe depression.
    • Severe depression may reduce motivation, functioning and ability to participate.
    • Consider medication side effects that may impair exercise, e.g. tricyclic antidepressants causing:
      • sedation
      • orthostatic hypotension.
    • Introduce exercise gradually to reduce injury risk.
    • Perform cardiovascular risk assessment before starting.
  • Contraindications / cautions
    • Use caution in patients with eating disorders such as anorexia nervosa.
    • Overtraining or fixation on exercise may worsen physical or mental health.
  • Availability
    • Walking groups.
    • Active transport.
    • Community sport/recreation programs.
    • Gym programs.
    • GP practice walking groups.
    • Exercise physiologist referral.
    • Medicare rebate may be available for up to 5 allied health sessions under chronic disease management arrangements if depressive symptoms are chronic.

2. Internet-based or computerised CBT

  • Intervention
    • Internet-based CBT or computerised CBT.
    • Structured psychological programs based on CBT principles.
    • Can be self-guided or clinician-supported depending on the program.
  • Indication
    • Depression and anxiety.
    • Useful for mild–moderate depression and anxiety.
    • May also be used in moderate–severe depression, depending on risk and support.
    • Particularly useful for:
      • rural/remote patients
      • mobility limitations
      • patients with limited access to face-to-face therapy.
  • Clinical relevance
    • Around 85% of patients with depression have significant anxiety symptoms.
    • iCBT programs can address both depression and anxiety.
  • Precautions
    • Assess risk of self-harm or suicide before recommending.
    • Not suitable as sole management when urgent, high-risk or complex care is needed.
    • May not suit patients with:
      • borderline personality disorder
      • antisocial personality disorder
      • substance dependence
      • severe complexity requiring direct clinician input.
    • Advise patient to report:
      • no improvement
      • worsening depression
      • worsening anxiety
      • suicidal ideation.
  • Availability / Australian resources
    • MoodGYM.
    • THIS WAY UP.
    • Mental Health Online.
    • MindSpot.
    • myCompass.
    • OnTrack.
    • beyondblue online programs.
    • eMHPrac resources.
    • Mindhealthconnect-style online program directories.
  • Evidence
    • NHMRC Level 1 evidence.

3. Bibliotherapy for depression

  • Intervention
    • Guided self-help using a structured book.
    • Patient works through the book independently.
    • GP role is to:
      • support
      • motivate
      • clarify questions
      • monitor progress
      • maintain follow-up.
  • Indication
    • Mild to moderate depression.
    • Subthreshold depressive symptoms.
    • Can be sole or adjunctive therapy.
    • Best suited to patients who:
      • have reading age above 12 years
      • are motivated
      • have a positive attitude towards self-help.
  • Not indicated
    • Severe depression.
    • Suicidal ideation.
    • Patients needing more intensive or immediate care.
  • Depression features
    • Key symptoms:
      • persistent sadness or low mood
      • marked loss of interest or pleasure.
    • Associated symptoms:
      • disturbed sleep
      • fatigue or low energy
      • guilt or worthlessness
      • reduced concentration
      • indecisiveness
      • psychomotor agitation or slowing
      • appetite change
      • suicidal thoughts or acts.
  • Severity guide
    • Subthreshold: fewer than five symptoms.
    • Mild: few symptoms beyond diagnostic threshold; minor functional impairment.
    • Moderate: symptoms cause some difficulty with everyday activities.
    • Severe: most symptoms present and marked functional impairment — bibliotherapy alone not appropriate.
  • Suggested follow-up
    • Initial consultation:
      • explain bibliotherapy
      • set expectations
      • ensure patient actively chooses this option
      • create treatment and follow-up plan.
    • Follow-up at around 2 weeks, ideally 30 minutes.
    • Discuss barriers, motivation and whether patient finds it acceptable.
    • Ongoing contact can be face-to-face, phone or email.
    • Many studies used weekly contact and 3-month follow-up.
  • Practical tips
    • Choose books that are:
      • culturally appropriate
      • linguistically appropriate
      • suitable for the patient’s reading level.
    • GP should be familiar with the recommended book.
    • Reassure patient this is one option, not dismissal or rejection.
    • Change plan if not helping.
  • Evidence
    • NHMRC Level 1 evidence.

Key takeaway

  • For mild to moderate depression, consider evidence-based non-drug options:
    • exercise
    • iCBT / CCBT
    • bibliotherapy.
  • These can be used alone or alongside medication/psychological therapy depending on severity, risk, patient preference and access.
  • For severe depression, suicidality, high risk, psychosis, bipolar disorder, substance dependence or significant functional impairment, do not rely on self-help or exercise alone; arrange more direct clinical care and safety planning.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.